Showing posts with label Board Bucket. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Board Bucket. Show all posts

Saturday, November 7, 2026

Policy vs Paper Clips

 

Your Weekly Staff Meeting | John Pearson Associates
Issue No. 284 of Your Weekly Staff Meeting (Aug. 26, 2013) features a dialogue on how to move micromanaging board members into a new-and-improved paradigm, “The Corporate Model.” The author quotes William Bowen, former Princeton University president, “Finding the appropriate balance between executive authority and board oversight is more likely to require strengthening the hand of the CEO than building up the powers of the board.” Plus, this reminder: check out my Management Buckets website with dozens of resources and downloadable worksheets for your staff meetings. 
-----------------------------------------------------------------------


Analysis Paralysis
vs. Rubber-Stamping 

Leaders and readers of this eNews fall into several categories:
  • CEOs, senior team members and church leaders who work with board members
  • Board members
  • People who will serve on boards in the future (Listen up!)
So let's be real here: much of what happens in the boardroom (nonprofit and corporate) is highly dysfunctional. In my opinion,
most governance fuzziness emanates
from unvoiced assumptions about
the board's role and the CEO's role.
 
Role clarity should always prompt a discussion about governance models: the Hands-on model, John Carver's Policy Governance model, the Board Policies Manual tool, and so many other options.  Yet with all of these models and resources available with a simple Google search, why is there still so much dysfunction? (Maybe no one reads this stuff?)

So here's a resource—with a very unique writing style—that will help clarify board roles and responsibilities. The author begins with the key question: what's Job #1 for a board? 
 
According to Eugene H. Fram, the most important job of the board is “to find the best possible person to manage the organization,
then stand back
and let that person manage.”
 
That's just one of dozens of quotable one-liners and wisdom-filled paragraphs in Policy vs. Paper Clips: How Using the Corporate Model Makes a Nonprofit Board More Efficient & Effective (3rd Edition).
 
“Volunteer directors who micromanage their agencies are, in blunt terms, cost centers for nonprofits, since they affect staff time so dramatically.” (Preach it!)
 
“Good governance helps eliminate the many hidden costs associated with pursuing activities that have nothing to do with the organization's purpose.” (Amen!)
 
“Your board should not be primarily focused on outcomes (e.g. success of specific programs) but concerned more about assessing the 'impacts' of those outcomes.” (High five!)
 
In putting flesh on the bones of the “generative mode” of governance (read my review of Governance as Leadership: Reframing the Work of Nonprofit Boards), the author says boards must focus more on the “what if” and other long-term questions.  
 
“Because directors' questions in this mode are different from the questions that they ask when day-to-day operations take up the agenda, they will find themselves focused on identifying available opportunities and vulnerabilities.
 
“This enables board members to tap their special expertise and professional experience in board discussions.  To draw upon this outside wealth of knowledge and perspectives, nonprofit executives should avoid acculturating board members to the 'conventional wisdom' of the organization. 
“In practical terms that means, for example,
that a director with marketing strategy experience
should be asked to help uncover new markets to serve
but not asked to write advertising copy.”
 
Then Fram adds, “Separating operational and policy issues is more complicated than it sounds.” 
 
Oh! I haven't shared this bonus factor: The entire book (240 pages) is a series of short email conversations between a fictitious nonprofit CEO (an acknowledged expert and speaker on the “Corporate” board model) and a golfing buddy who just joined a nonprofit board.
 
Fram mentions two board sins, analysis paralysis and rubber-stamping.His solution? Use the “Corporate Model” to focus the board on policy, not operations.  The quick-reading email dialogue between two friends eliminates the typical boring governance rhetoric (yada, yada, yada) and replaces the blue sky stuff with in-the-trenches, to-the-point conversation and thoughtful next steps.  
 
About every other chapter, I would inject, “Wait a minute. That wouldn't work!” And then in the next paragraph, the rookie board member would email my objection to his mentor—and the practical drill-down response would satisfy.  (I may steal this brilliant idea: an entire book of email conversations. It works.)
 
The emails are segmented into 12 chapters including: 
  • The Corporate Model: A Board Alternative
  • How the Model Is Structured: Intentional Simplicity
  • Assessment and the Model: The CEO Cannot Be Insecure
  • The Model and the Future: The Planning and Resource Committee
  • The Model at Work: The Executive Committee and Its Responsibilities
  • The Model Creates a New Culture: Trust Is the Critical Factor
  • The Model and Commitment: Board Members Must Be Involved
Practical charts are included like the five lists detailing the differences between the Corporate Model and the Traditional Model. The last chapter asks, “Is your organization ready for the Corporate Model?” and features 23 pages of very, very practical Q & A.
 
To order this book from Amazon, click on this title: Policy vs. Paper Clips: How Using the Corporate Model Makes a Nonprofit Board More Efficient & Effective (3rd Edition), by Eugene H. Fram with Vicki Brown.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
Your Weekly Staff Meeting Questions:
1) In one email, the rookie board member asks, “We also need more information about how to keep board members truly involved without the ego satisfaction that often comes from dealing with operational issues.”  Have you ever considered that a board member's temptation to micromanage might be related to ego satisfaction?
2) PowerPoint Rules? One email mentions this: “Directors hate [PowerPoint presentations] when they are far too long, the slides are overwhelmingly dense, or they touch on issues tangential to the case being made, or frankly are being used to stifle real dialogue).” The author prefers a limit  of 10 slides. Interesting! Do your board or staff PowerPoints encourage micromanagement and/or stifle dialogue? 
-----------------------------------------------------------------------


The Meeting Before the Meeting
Insights from Mastering the Management Buckets: 20 Critical Competencies for Leading Your Business or Nonprofit
 
If I could add another ball to my Meetings Bucket chapter (20), in Mastering the Management Buckets, it would be this wisdom from John Maxwell: “The secret to a good meeting is the meeting before the meeting.”
 
The “no surprises” rule is critical for the key people in each meeting—and typically, that means you must meet with them in advance.  Maxwell preaches: 
  • If you can’t have the meeting before the meeting, don’t have the meeting. 
  • If you do have the meeting before the meeting, but it doesn’t go well, don’t have the meeting. 
  • If you have the meeting before the meeting and it goes as well as you hoped, then have the meeting!
To read my review of Maxwell's chapter on meetings, click here: Leadership Gold: Lessons I’ve Learned from a Lifetime of Leading. For more resources, plus book recommendations from the Meetings Bucket, click here.
 
    

MORE RESOURCES:

• BLOG: Pails in Comparison
• SUBSCRIBE: Your Weekly Staff Meeting eNews
• JOHN'S BOOK REVIEWS: on Amazon 
• WEBSITE: Management Buckets
• BLOG: Governance of Christ-Centered Organizations
• PODCASTS: John Pearson's Buckets Podcasts 

NOTICE! Issues No. 1 to 657 of Your Weekly Staff Meeting (2006 to 2025), previously archived on Typepad.com are slowly (!) being moved to this new blogsite: John Pearson's Buckets Blog.

ECFA BLOG on “Governance of Christ-centered Organizations”  
Add your thoughts to John's latest blog post for boards, "6 Board Dysfunctions" including when the board chair thinks he or she is the CEO's boss.









Thursday, October 22, 2026

Owning Up

    

Issue No. 170 of Your Weekly Staff Meeting (Jan. 11, 2010) features a book with 14 questions every board member needs to ask. (Ditto your staff members.)  The author says that “if you have no appetite for risk, you shouldn’t be on a board; it will inhibit the CEO from making bold and necessary moves and potentially company-saving bets.” And this reminder: check out my Management Buckets website with dozens of resources and downloadable worksheets for your staff meetings.

















The 14 Questions Every Board Needs to Ask

The “go-to adviser” for corporate boards and CEOs, Ram Charan, says that boards must “own up” to its accountability for the performance of the organization and reinvent the content of their work and modus operandi.  He preaches, “Governance now means leadership.” 

Board governance often has fuzzy boundaries and is never easy—but this excellent author/authority has 14 cringe-type questions. If you’re a long-time reader of this eNews, you may recall my enthusiasm for two of Charan’s other books: the best-seller Execution: The Discipline of Getting Things Done, with Larry Bossidy, (Issue 29) and Leaders at All Levels: Deepening Your Talent Pool to Solve the Succession Crisis (Issue 73). His stuff is reliable, insightful, and best of all, highly practical.

Charan doesn’t waste words—firing this question onto the board table in the first paragraph of Chapter 1/Question 1: Is Our Board Composition Right for the Challenge? He writes, “The role of the board has unmistakably transitioned from passive governance to active leadership with a delicate balance of avoiding micromanaging. It’s leadership as a group, not leadership by an appointed person.” He adds, “With the right composition, a board can create value; with the wrong or inappropriate composition, it can easily destroy value.”

He recommends that every board member and board prospect complete a “skill assessment matrix” to assess the board’s overall strengths and weaknesses.  “The process is important because a board full of generalists is not good enough anymore,” he warns. Reference checking of board members (well beyond the basic level) is now an absolute necessity. The biggest red flag to avoid: a board nominee with a big ego.

The discussion of board member succession is worth the price of the book. Insights: 1) the process may take up to three years; 2) many CEOs are limiting their service on other boards to just two, or often just their own board; 3) to get the right mix of board members—for rapidly changing needs—many boards are encouraging incumbents to step down early. (Not easy—but critical.) Perhaps most critical: “Board service is always more attractive when the prospective director knows the board has its act together—that the board is thorough in covering its bases and functions well as a group.”

Effective boards will want to use this book at an annual board retreat—or address one or two questions per board meeting over the next year or more.  The book can also be read topically, based on your current hot issues. I started with Question 13: How Do We Stop From Micromanaging?  All 14 have zinger qualities to them. My favorites, based on my board consulting work, include:
   • Question 11: How Can Executive Sessions Help the Board Own Up?
   • Question 12: How Can Our Board Self-Evaluation Improve Our Functioning and Our Output?
   • Question 2: Are We Addressing the Risks That Could Send Our Company Over the Cliff?
   • Question 4: Are We Well Prepared to Name Our Next CEO?
   • Question 5: Does Our Board Really Own the Company’s Strategy?

The best practices for the strategy question are both brilliant and practical—but the CEO will need to dramatically increase face time with board members. But the pay-off could be huge. He notes, “Strategy should always be in the back of directors’ minds. It helps to have the strategy brief or a two-page sheet of bullet points in the binder for every meeting.”  Then Charan cautions us, “If the board and the CEO have lasting substantive differences, they have a choice: stay with the strategy or replace the CEO. Consider that management has a shelf life too, just like the strategy.”

To order this book from Amazon, click on the title for Owning Up: The 14 Questions Every Board Member Needs to Ask, by Ram Charan.

















BONUS! Owning Up is one of "18 Best Board Books" I recommend. Click here for the list. Plus, click here for the index to 14 blogs I wrote on each of the 14 questions in Owning Up, on the blogsite for ECFA Governance of Christ-Centered Organizations.

YOUR WEEKLY STAFF MEETING QUESTIONS:

........................................................................
1)
Charan says that “the business landscape has changed. The game has changed. What boards do needs to change as well.” From your perspective, is our board keeping up with the change?

2) The authors adds, “The financial crisis of 2008 laid bare a long buried truth: that many boards do not really own the strategy of their company.”  Give our board a rating from 1 to 5 (5 is high). “How strongly does our board own our strategy?”

........................................................................

The 20% Investment
Insights from Mastering the Management Buckets: 20 Critical Competencies for Leading Your Business or Nonprofit

One of the big ideas in the Board Bucket, Chapter 14, in Mastering the Management Buckets is to grow a great board.  A Chinese proverb says that if you want one year of prosperity, grow grain. If you want 10 years of prosperity, grow trees. If you want 100 years of prosperity, grow people.

A common rule of thumb for large organizations is that CEOs invest about 20 percent of their time on board-related work, including meeting face-to-face with individual board members. That’s one day a week.  If you’re the CEO, how are you doing on that best practice?

For more books, insights and resources, visit the Board Bucket webpage.

MORE RESOURCES:

• BLOG: Pails in Comparison
• SUBSCRIBE: Your Weekly Staff Meeting eNews
• JOHN'S BOOK REVIEWS: on Amazon 
• WEBSITE: Management Buckets
• BLOG: Governance of Christ-Centered Organizations
• PODCASTS: John Pearson's Buckets Podcasts 

NOTICE! Issues No. 1 to 657 of Your Weekly Staff Meeting (2006 to 2025), previously archived on Typepad.com are slowly (!) being moved to this blogsite you are on now (John Pearson's Buckets Blog).

Monday, October 12, 2026

The Hero’s Farewell: What Happens When CEOs Retire

 

Issue No. 212 of Your Weekly Staff Meeting
 (March 22, 2011) highlights a fascinating look at four types of CEO retirement transitions: monarchs, generals, ambassadors and governors. And this reminder: check out my Management Buckets website with dozens of resources and downloadable worksheets for your staff meetings.















4 Types of CEO Retirement Transitions

In my Management Buckets workshops, I talk about the four levels of mastering the 20 critical competencies (buckets):
   --Level 1: I don’t know what I don’t know.
   --Level 2: I know what I don’t know.
   --Level 3: I have an action plan to address what I know I don’t know.
   --Level 4: I can coach and mentor others. I can teach the course!

So feeling pretty smug that I’ve been around the block once or twice, I was startled to realize that I was back at Level 1 regarding what happens when CEOs retire. Wow. I learned a lot from this book—and, like all great books, I found immediate value in attaching a memorable label to four kinds of CEO retirement. Recommended to me by Paul McKaughan (a “retired/ambassador” CEO), I’ve already recommended this book to more than 20 other CEOs.

First published in 1988 by Harvard prof Jeffrey Sonnenfeld, the book is part history, part expose and part therapy.  “This is a book,” he begins, “about how the management succession process involving chief executive officers of major corporations is affected by the heroic view that CEOs have of themselves.  Some plan carefully and choose wisely who will succeed them. Others fight the process and must be forced out in what can be traumatic episodes for the CEOs and the organizations.”

Painstakingly researched (five years and 50 personal interviews), the book describes four types of CEO retirement transitions:
   --The Monarch’s Departure. “Monarchs leave their thrones only through their death, ill health, or as with [Boston Consulting Group’s Bruce] Henderson, a palace revolt.”
   --The General’s Departure. “Although as with monarchs, the leader’s heroic mission is important to generals, it is not as important as are their needs for a heroic identity.  The generals’ greatest barrier to exit is their identification with heroic stature.  They treasure the respect and recognition they have earned, and in leaving high office, they leave behind a great deal of their self-worth.”
   --The Ambassador’s Departure. “Ambassadors, like generals, also remain within their firms after retirement. Unlike the generals, however, the ambassadors do not seek to return to top office positions. They work to support rather than to subvert their successors. Guided by an inner sense of accomplishment and fulfillment, the ambassadors are not searching for more battles to further prove their heroic valor.”
   --The Governor’s Departure. “In contrast to the open-ended reign of the monarch, the general’s eager return to office, or the ambassador’s maintaining of advisory status, the retiring governor-like business leader usually leaves office for a completely new activity.  The governors have long had extensive interests outside their firms.  Retirement for them is often merely a career change as they turn to purse outside interests. After they disengage from their firms, their careers do not fade into the sunset.  Any new activities tend to be leadership roles and not solely board memberships.”

There’s more. All interesting, even fascinating, at this insider’s glimpse into decades of boardroom transitions—not all pretty!  Along the journey, Sonnenfeld’s color commentary informs and teaches.  What does it take for CEOs to give up the “psychological perks” of the office? He quotes another Harvard prof’s advice to an incoming CEO: “The first step in a mess like this is to reduce chaos to disorder.” A brilliant one-liner.

While the ambassador style seems the most God-honoring, the author points out that some of his ambassador subjects weren’t exactly humble.  Another insight: Withthrop Knowlton, Harper & Row, “cautioned that the chief executive’s natural tendency to close his or her administration in a ‘blaze of glory often leads them to become increasingly drawn inward…to work harder on corporate problems in the last year or two.’ He suggested that chief executives should instead be encouraged to join other boards for exposure to other exit patterns and to broaden their interests and identities.”

Here’s my surprising recommendation: read this in your 40s and 50s—don’t wait until you’re in your 60s.  There is great insight on both the way up and the way out of the organization.   

To order this book from Amazon, click on this title: The Hero’s Farewell: What Happens When CEOs Retire by Jeffrey Sonnenfeld.
















Your Weekly Staff Meeting Questions: 

........................................................................
1) According to Irving Shapiro of Du Pont, “The first function of a new CEO is to provide for his succession.”  Why might it be important for a brand new CEO, or for that matter, any leader or manager, to plan for his or her succession?


2) CEOs who stayed on as ambassadors and wise elder statesmen, according to the author, often were safe havens for conversations with other corporate officers.  They also encouraged the new CEO because the CEO job can be a lonely one.  What might be some of the up-sides and down-sides of a retiring CEO becoming an ambassador?

BONUS! For 12 more resources on succession planning, see my review of Lost in Transition.
........................................................................

14 Questions Board Members Must Ask
Insights from Mastering the Management Buckets: 20 Critical Competencies for Leading Your Business or Nonprofit

One of the big ideas in the Board Bucket, Chapter 14, in Mastering the Management Buckets is to get the right board members on the board bus—and then ensure they ask themselves tough questions.

I’ve worked with boards that use Ram Charan’s excellent book, Owning Up: The 14 Questions Every Board Member Needs to Ask.  Effective boards will want to use this book at an annual board retreat—or address one or two questions per board meeting over the next year or more.  The book can also be read topically, based on your current hot issues. I started with Question 13: How Do We Stop From Micromanaging?  All 14 have zinger qualities to them. My favorites, based on my board consulting work, include:
   --Question 11: How Can Executive Sessions Help the Board Own Up?
   --Question 12: How Can Our Board Self-Evaluation Improve Our Functioning and Our Output?
   --Question 2: Are We Addressing the Risks That Could Send Our Company Over the Cliff?
   --Question 4: Are We Well Prepared to Name Our Next CEO?
   --Question 5: Does Our Board Really Own the Company’s Strategy?

Check out this book and other resources in the Board Bucket.

MORE RESOURCES:

• BLOG: Pails in Comparison
• SUBSCRIBE: Your Weekly Staff Meeting eNews
• JOHN'S BOOK REVIEWS: on Amazon 
• WEBSITE: Management Buckets
• BLOG: Governance of Christ-Centered Organizations
• PODCASTS: John Pearson's Buckets Podcasts 

NOTICE! Issues No. 1 to 657 of Your Weekly Staff Meeting (2006 to 2025), previously archived on Typepad.com are slowly (!) being moved to this blogsite you are on now (John Pearson's Buckets Blog).

Wednesday, September 30, 2026

The Imperfect Board Member - 2026

 

Your Weekly Staff Meeting | John Pearson Associates
Issue No. 693 of Your Weekly Staff Meeting (Sept. 30, 2026) admits we all must work with “imperfect” board members—but Jim Brown has refreshed ideas for you. Plus, click here for back issues posted at the new location for John Pearson’s Buckets Blog, including my review of two new leadership books. And check out these bite-sized book summaries (7- to 9-minute videos)—perfect for your weekly staff meeting.
 

The Imperfect Board Member is the perfect book for your next board retreat or your "10 Minutes for Governance" slot at your next board meeting.

10 Boardroom Shifts Since 2006

Brilliant idea! Take a great book that I’ve recommended to every board I’ve consulted with since 2006—and enrich that book with more resources and practical help. Congrats to Jim Brown for this 20th anniversary expanded edition—just published.

The Imperfect Board Member: 
Discovering the Seven Disciplines of 
Governance Excellence 

(20th Anniversary Updated & Expanded Edition)
by Jim Brown (Sept. 29, 2026)

I’m often asked by nonprofit CEOs and board members, “What’s the best board governance book we should read?” (You already know my answer: “It depends.”) That’s why in 2018-2019, I created my list of “18 Best Board Books.” The Imperfect Board Member is Book #2. (Read my 2006 review. See the list of 18 board books, plus five “bonus books.”)

Jim Brown, the founder of OrgHealth, consults with corporate boards, nonprofit boards, and church boards (he’s one brave guy!)—and knows his way around the boardroom. Here are seven reasons you’ll appreciate this 20th anniversary update:

#1. Board Members Will Read it! The “fable” format is real life. David, the CEO in this story, wakes up in a cold sweat—six nights, six nightmares. Board members will read and identify with the organizational challenges at work—and at home. (Spoiler alert! A pastor mentors this corporate guy on governance excellence!)

#2. Lencioni Loves It! Patrick Lencioni, who wrote the foreword to the book, writes: “Finally, a book about boards that isn’t boring!” (High praise from an author who knows something about writing business fables.)

#3. Twenty Years of Change Explained. What’s different now in 2026 versus 2006? Must-read: Chapter 14, “Twenty Years of Change in the Boardroom.” (Brilliant!)

#4. Memorable Model. Part 2 of this expanded book drills down on Brown’s “Secret Formula for Organizational Effectiveness” (not secret anymore!) and “The Seven Disciplines of Governance Excellence.” (A colleague who read the book in 2006 can still quote the seven disciplines—because they’re memorable.)

#5. New Coaching Highlights. “Compass icons” in the fable spotlight 10 coaching highlights (with application) in Part 3’s short chapters. You’ll be tempted to read these first: “Manipulating the Board,” “Forgiveness Versus Permission,” “Handling Conflict,” and “The Power of Owning Mistakes.”

#6. New Nonprofit & Church Board Insights. Read the very practical chapter on “Governing Churches and Charities,” including an affirming section, “What Churches and Charities Can Teach Corporations.”

#7. More Book Recommendations! Brown includes a recommended reading list of 15 titles—plus short paragraphs for each book explaining, “Why this book?” (Brilliant.)

SO INSIGHTFUL! Brown details 10 shifts in the chapter, “Twenty Years of Change in the Boardroom.” (Why doesn’t every second edition of a book do this?) He notes that the shifts “…form the backdrop for everything boards must navigate today. Each represents both progress and a new layer of complexity.” Aligned with the new coaching highlights in this 2026 update, the shifts address board culture, chair leadership, and the complexity of governing organizations with multiple owner groups.

Here are five of the 10 shifts over the last 20 years. (Each shift includes a lesson to be learned.)
   • From Compliance to Strategic Stewardship
   • From CEO-Controlled Agendas to Shared Leadership at the Top
   • From Not Enough Information to Too Much at Once
   • From Technology as Infrastructure to Technology as Strategy
   • From Annual Evaluations to Continuous Board Learning

BOARD BOOK/BOARD RETREAT. If I were still a CEO (I’m saying that a lot lately), I’d create a discussion guide for The Imperfect Board Member and inspire the board to make this their book-of-the-year; or use the guide for pre-reading prior to the next board retreat. (See Tool #13 from ECFA, “Board Retreat Read-and-Reflect Worksheets.”)

MORE RESOURCES!
Jim Brown also publishes two eNewsletters:
[  ] The Imperfect Board eNews (subscribe here)
[  ] The Imperfect Church Leader eNews (subscribe here)

THE IMPERFECT CEO! Jim Brown is one busy guy. Also in 2026, he wrote The Imperfect CEO: Making the Climb to Organizational Health.
[   ] Read my review.
[   ] Order from Amazon.
[   ] View the interview with Jim Brown on the “Life After Ministry” podcast (31 min.) .
[   ] View the summary video (7 minutes) of my review of The Imperfect CEO.

 

THERE’S MORE!
Raise your hand if your board chair has a business card that reads, “Cultural Architect.” Brown believes that every board member helps shape culture, “but the chair is the architect. The best chairs are more than meeting managers. They’re facilitators, tone-setters, and bridge-builders." He adds, “And the chair’s work doesn’t stop when the gavel drops,” because board chairs “see culture as a living system that needs constant tending."

This reminded me of David McKenna’s book, Call of the Chair (read my review). He defines nine roles of the board chair: Missionary, Model, Mentor, Manager, Moderator, Mediator, Monitor, Master, and Maestro. 

Should the CEO also serve as board chair? (This is common in some companies and organizations, very uncommon in others.) Brown confesses that when he wrote The Imperfect Board Member in 2006, he “sidestepped one of governance’s most loaded debates.” Now in 2026, this gutsy guy writes an entire chapter: “To Chair or Not to Chair: Why Splitting the Roles Makes Sense for Most." (Don’t skip pages 205-206, “Four Common Risks of CEO-Chair Duality” and “Recognizing the Dark Side.”)

Bottom Line for Me: The Imperfect Board Member (2026 edition) remains on my “18 Best Board Books” list. Santiago “Jimmy” Mellado, president and CEO of Compassion International, calls this new update “an indispensable guide to governance.” I just ordered the book for the elder board at our church.

TO ORDER FROM AMAZON, click on the title for The Imperfect Board Member: Discovering the Seven Disciplines of Governance Excellence (20th Anniversary Updated & Expanded Edition), by Jim Brown. 


 
YOUR WEEKLY STAFF MEETING QUESTIONS:
1) What book did you read 20 or more years ago that needs an updated and expanded edition now in 2026?
2) In the foreword to The Imperfect Board Member (2006), Patrick Lencioni wrote, “The author—a friend of mine—often jokes that a greeter at WalMart gets more orientation than most board members ever do. We all know that’s no joke. It’s true for boards of every description. And it’s appalling. Although it sounds extreme, management guru Peter Drucker wrote, ‘There is one thing all boards have in common . . . They do not function.’” QUESTION: How would your three newest board members evaluate the recruitment and orientation process they endured? (There’s help!)
    
   
SECOND READS: Fresh Solutions From Classic Books
You have changed—and your problems have changed—since you read this the first time!

Book #60 of 99: $50 Fine for Boring Meetings!

For your team meeting this week, inspire a team member to lead your “10 Minutes for Lifelong Learning” session by featuring Book #60 of 99 in our series, “Second Reads.” The big idea: REREAD TO LEAD! Discover how your favorite books (and articles) still have more to teach you and the people you’re coaching and mentoring.

Unbroken: 
A World War II Story of Survival, 
Resilience, and Redemption

by Laura Hillenbrand (Nov. 16, 2010)
 
Wait…what? Yes…I’m recommending the page-turner, Unbroken, as an antidote to boring meetings. Learn why. 
   • Read my review (Issue No. 308, Oct. 2, 2014).
   • Order from Amazon.
   • Management Bucket #20 of 20: The Meetings Bucket

$50 Fine for Boring Meetings! After 30 years of CEO work, I turned in my keys and credit cards at the end of 2005, and there are days I wish I could rewind the video—and get a do-over on my leadership years.

For example, I would institute a $50 fine for every boring staff meeting—and I would double the fine for myself if anyone caught me leading an uninspired, ho-hum meeting. Today, I would follow “Pearson’s Radical Wall Poster Team-building Exercise: 4 Easy Steps.” One idea: plan a “Book-of-the-Quarter” event. 

P.S. Oops! By the way, if you’re taking notes, in my 99-book journey through “Second Reads: Reread to Lead,” I mistakenly spotlighted Thinkpak - A Brainstorming Card Deck in both #60 of 99 and #23 of 99. (My bad!) So, this is a substitute blog for #60 of 99. (At least I admit my mistakes!)
 

CLICK HERE FOR BOOKS BY JOHN

   
View the video summary of “Mistake #4: Not Learning How to Listen. Way too late in life, I’m learning ‘the case for listening’” (8 min.). (Lee Strobel was talking. I wasn't listening. LOL.) See the workbook, Mastering Mistake Making: My 25 Memorable Mistakes—and What I Learned (10 Minutes for Lifelong Learning Workbook), by John Pearson with Jason Pearson.

NOTICE! Effective Oct. 1, 2025, all 657 eNews issues, previously archived on Typepad.com are slowly (!) being moved to a new website here at John Pearson's Buckets Blog.


The Imperfect CEO

View the summary video (7 minutes) of John’s review of The Imperfect CEO: Making the Climb to Organizational Health, by Jim Brown. (Read the review.)

BONUS! As of today, 32 video podcasts (7 to 9 minutes each) are posted here. Perfect life-long learning snippets for your weekly staff meeting.

MORE RESOURCES:

• BLOG: Pails in Comparison
• SUBSCRIBE: Your Weekly Staff Meeting eNews
• JOHN'S BOOK REVIEWS: on Amazon 
• WEBSITE: Management Buckets
• BLOG: Governance of Christ-Centered Organizations
• PODCASTS: John Pearson's Buckets Podcasts 


Transforming Church Boards

“Perhaps the most important difference between corporate governance and church board leadership is the task of discernment.” That’s from Book 3 of 3 in the series, Transforming Church Boards: For Churches in Transition (read my review), by Dennis Baker, David C. Fisher, and John Vawter (yes, the same guy who wrote the hilarious golf book!). For more book reviews, visit the Pails in Comparison Blog.














Friday, September 25, 2026

4 Steps for Board Member Recruitment

 

Your Weekly Staff Meeting | John Pearson Associates
Issue No. 260 of Your Weekly Staff Meeting (Oct. 30, 2012) features a new governance toolkit for your next board meeting. The resource from ECFA includes a short DVD and viewing guides for each board member. Plus check out my Management Buckets website with dozens of resources and downloadable worksheets for your staff meetings.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------



Board Recruitment: Don't Propose Marriage on Your First Date!

A Chinese proverb says, “The best time to plant a tree was 20 years ago. The second best time is today.”

That’s also relevant counsel for your board member recruitment process.  The best time to discern board member criteria and qualifications is before you invite inappropriate people onto your board. But moving from “slot-filling” to a thoughtful discernment process is not easy.
 
There’s help!  The new ECFA Governance Toolbox Series has launched and the first title in the series is “Recruiting Board Members: Leveraging the 4 Phases of Board Recruitment—Cultivation, Recruitment, Orientation and Engagement.”
 
This “View-Inspire-Engage” toolbox includes a 13-minute DVD, 12 Board Member Read-and-Engage Viewing Guides, and a Facilitator Guide with just-in-time help to engage your board on this fork-in-the-road core competency.  The Facilitator Guide provides three discussion options: 
   Option 1: 15-30 minute board discussion
   Option 2: 30-60 minute discussion
   Option 3: Board Retreat (or a 2-hour session)
 
The fast-moving DVD features a short In-the-Trenches Board Story on recruitment: “The Shortest Board Term in the History of the World.”  It’s humorous, but poignant. Perhaps your board members will see themselves in the “got-the-binder-joined-the-board” video clip.
 
When viewing the video, each board member will follow along with the colorful 20-page Read-and-Engage Viewing Guide—and will then interact with the 27 self-assessment questions from the four phases of board recruitment.  Example:
 
SELF-ASSESSMENT QUESTIONS:
How strongly do you agree or disagree with the following statements?
 
CULTIVATION: “We follow the best practice of ‘dating’ a board prospect—over an appropriate period of time—before ‘proposing marriage.’”
 
CULTIVATION: “We ensure that a board prospect’s spouse, family (and sometimes employer) is aware of the ‘time, talent and treasure’ requirements of board service.”
 
RECRUITMENT: “Compared to the due diligence our senior leaders exercise when hiring staff, our board exercises a high level of due diligence when discerning a board prospect’s suitability for board service.”
 
RECRUITMENT: “We go slow and rely on the 18- to 36-month cultivation process by encouraging potential prospects to serve in key volunteer roles to assess their diligence and faithfulness.”
 
ORIENTATION: “Our orientation process includes required reading of at least one governance book, such as The Imperfect Board Member, by Jim Brown, or Owning Up: The 14 Questions Every Board Member Needs to Ask, by Ram Charan.” (Read the blog series: 14 posts.)
 
ORIENTATION: “Our orientation process involves at least 5 to 10 hours of orientation, over a period of several months, and concludes with a written or online feedback survey.”
 
ENGAGEMENT: “We know and leverage ‘The 3 Powerful S’s’ (Spiritual Gifts, Strengths and Styles) of our board members. We are also students of our CEO’s unique strengths and giftedness—and his/her preferred working style.”
 
ENGAGEMENT: “We can point, with delight, to numerous examples of how God-honoring board members—fully engaged—have leveraged their giftedness to help us make strategic, fork-in-the-road, spiritually discerning decisions to the glory of God!”
 
These are just 8 of the 27 questions listed in the toolbox. In addition, there is a starter page on board qualifications, “Board Nominees Must Meet Our 6 Ds Criteria.” They include: 1) Discerning Decision-Maker, 2) Demonstrated Passion, 3) Documented Team Player, 4) Diligent and Faithful Participant, 5) Doer (he or she “walks the talk” and reference checks affirm a God-honoring lifestyle and character), and 6) Donor.
 
The Facilitator Guide provides a link to a hidden webpage with bonus resources and templates, such as a sample table of contents (31 tabs) for a Board Nominee Orientation Binder, plus “The Board Bucket” chapter from my book, Mastering the Management Buckets.  I’ve worked with ECFA on the concept and writing of the first two toolkits—so I recommend them highly!  More titles are coming.
 
To order from ECFA, click on this link: ECFA Governance Toolbox Series No. 1:  Recruiting Board Members. 

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Your Weekly Staff Meeting Questions:
1) The DVD in the ECFA Governance Toolbox Series quotes Elton Trueblood, “Pious shoddy is still shoddy.” How would you describe your board’s competencies in each of the four phases of: Cultivation, Recruitment, Orientation, and Engagement? Shoddy? Pious Shoddy? Excellent?

 2) In the Recruitment phase, the toolkit suggests that a prospect, prior to serving on the board, should already be a generous giver per Matthew 6:21, “Where your treasure is, there your heart will be also.” The viewing guide notes, “Many organizations define ‘generous’ as prioritizing your organization in the Top-3 of a person’s annual giving. Board members at all income levels can be generous.” What is our board’s expectation (or policy) on board member generosity?
 



Honing the Smithereens Out of a Perfectly Adequate System
Insights from Mastering the Management Buckets: 20 Critical Competencies for Leading Your Business or Nonprofit

One of the big ideas in Chapter 18, The Systems Bucket, in my book, Mastering the Management Buckets, is to resist the urge to tinker endlessly to perfect the flawless system. Perfection is not the goal.
 
It’s not always prudent to wait until all your ducks are in a row.  Sometimes even systems people must agree that “good is good enough” and it’s time to launch the project. Too much tinkering to get it “right” may create an unintended consequence—overhead overload.
 
Some of your team members are systems zealots and have overused skills. Some may hone the smithereens out of a perfectly adequate system. Others, addicted to perfection, rarely finish a project.  You may have a team member—a genius—who is unable to tolerate non-geniuses. “Why don’t they get it?” So, what should you do?
 
Read Chapter 18 and check out the resources on the Systems Bucket webpage, including a unique add-water-and-stir book that is amazingly simple, yet profound. FYI: For Your Improvement: A Guide for Development and Coaching, from two feedback experts.
 

  

 

MORE RESOURCES:
• BLOG: Pails in Comparison
• SUBSCRIBE: Your Weekly Staff Meeting eNews
• JOHN'S BOOK REVIEWS: on Amazon 
• WEBSITE: Management Buckets
• BLOG: Governance of Christ-Centered Organizations
• PODCASTS: John Pearson's Buckets Podcasts 

NOTICE! Effective Oct. 1, 2025, all 657 eNews issues, previously archived on Typepad.com are slowly (!) being moved to a new website here at John Pearson's Buckets Blog

ECFA Blog on “Governance of Christ-centered Organizations”  
Read John's blog post, "More Huckster Than Holy?" and check out the new ECFA Governance Toolbox Series No. 1: Recruiting Board Members (DVD and Viewing Guides).












What Is Strategy?

  Issue No. 280 of  Your Weekly Staff Meeting  (June 24, 2013) introduces a  Harvard Business Review  article—a classic from 1996—on “What ...