Friday, October 3, 2025

A CEO for All Seasons

 


Issue No. 658 of Your Weekly Staff Meeting (Oct. 3, 2025) features a new book coming Oct. 7—describing the four seasons of a CEO. The “middle stretch” is the most dangerous due to complacency. Plus, click here for recent issues posted at the NEW site for John Pearson’s Buckets Blog, including How Leaders Lose Their Way: And How to Make Sure It Doesn't Happen to You, by Peter Greer and Jill Heisey. Also, check out the 20 management buckets (core competencies).


LOL! According to the new book, A CEO for All Seasons, when you become CEO, “All of a sudden, you have a lot more friends.” And… "You have much funnier jokes!"

IMPORTANT NOTICE! Effective Oct. 1, 2025, all 657 eNews issues, previously archived on Typepad.com are slowly (!) being moved to a new website here. New book reviews will also be archived here at John Pearson’s Buckets Blog. Or, click here for John’s recent book reviews on Amazon.
 

The 4 Seasons of a CEO

Yikes! According to this issue’s companion book, CEO Excellence“Thirty percent of Fortune 500 CEOs last fewer than three years, and two out of five new CEOs are perceived to be failing within eighteen months.”

So four senior partners at McKinsey, the authors of a CEO for All Seasons, urge you to reflect on what season you’re in: 
   • Stepping Up: Becoming a high-potential CEO candidate.
   • Starting Strong: Transitioning into the CEO role.
   • Staying Ahead: Navigating the middle years.
   • Sending It Forward: Transitioning out of the CEO role. 
 
A CEO for All Seasons: 
Mastering the Cycles of Leadership, 

by Carolyn Dewar, Scott Keller, Vikram Malhotra, 
and Kurt Strovink (Oct. 7, 2025)
 
LOL! The co-authors of A CEO for All Seasons report that “The day you become CEO, all the attention becomes laser-focused on you, often in ways that distort reality.” They quote the CEO of Allianz SE, Oliver Bäte, “People change their face when you become CEO. Everybody gives you partial information. All of a sudden, you have a lot more friends. You have much funnier jokes. Your ties are much more beautiful than they were the day before.”

Nasdaq’s CEO, Adena Friedman, agrees: “Once you become CEO, the relationship with the team changes, and what used to be a suggestion or idea is suddenly taken as a ‘command,’ which was certainly not the intention.”

THE PROBLEM. The authors warn that “All this attention and power can quickly create a celebrity CEO phenomenon where the transition becomes all about you.” They quote the CEO of a hospital system, who observes, “I see a lot of CEOs who are very much about themselves. They have a lot of ego, and some arrogance . . . and they view the job as a destination, not a journey.”

THE SOLUTION. Dr. Robert Gross continues, “I think when you’re a CEO, you’re a concierge, and you’re responsible for the care and feeding of your institution.

“Concierge” is just one of dozens of fresh insights you’ll pick up from this book—plus, perhaps, a new lexicon for CEOs, board members, and senior team members. Example: “leadership factories.” The authors predict that in the future, the “best of the best” leaders will turn their organizations into “leadership factories” where highly skilled people will focus on robust succession planning and excellent problem-solving.

“Leading through leaders” is just one of seven hallmarks of leaders who will “excel in the CEO role into the future.” (Ask your board what the other six hallmarks might be—or read this book!)

More from this leadership lexicon:
   • Laddering: the clinical psychology interview technique that the authors used when interviewing 83 "best of the best" CEOs for this book.
   • The Lake Wobegon Effect: the “human tendency to overestimate our own abilities, achievements, and performance.”
   • The Primacy Effect: “You never get a second chance to make a first impression.”
   • Entertainment: Netflix’s CEO warns about understanding the press: “They want to be truth tellers, but they’re forced to be entertainers.”
   • Play Big Ball: “…spend time on things that no one else can in ways that magnify your effectiveness without getting mired in things that don’t make a difference.”
   • A Players: When assessing talent, “Put A players in critical roles, move C players out, and help B players succeed.” (Read more in Leaders at All LevelsRead my review.)

Using a rigorous research approach, the McKinsey team began studying the CEOs who led the world’s 1,000 largest companies in the last 15 years. Adding more criteria, including “best CEO lists,” they landed on just 200 leaders—and interviewed 83. And get this: “these CEOs were able to sense, learn, and act so quickly that they never endured a losing season.” And this: “…those in business who achieve the most tend to be those who are the best at getting better.”

The insights run just 112 pages, plus a 25-page appendix with “reflection exercises” for CEOs, the senior team, and the board. The second appendix includes one-page profiles of 46 “exceptional CEOS we interviewed along the way.” (And I checked—your bio is not there!)

OPERATIONAL CADENCE. “The best CEOs take the time early in their tenure to think through the tempo and template for accountability and execution. This means playing a hands-on role in setting up weekly, monthly, quarterly, and annual meetings with individuals, committees, the team as a whole…” and others. 

While noting that every organization’s “operating rhythm” is different, “a common template is to get the top team together weekly for a relatively informal sixty-minute meeting to touch base, monthly for a more formal half day, and once a year at an off-site.” (Read more in Death by MeetingRead my review.)

WHAT ME—COMPLACENT? Then there’s this wake-up call! “We’ve never met a CEO who told us, ‘Yep, I’m becoming complacent.’” During the “middle stretch” of a CEO’s tenure, many CEOs believe that complacency will be the toughest challenge they face. “Said another way, becoming a successful CEO is hard, but staying successful is even harder.”

And get this: “More than half of the companies on the Fortune 500 list in the year 2000 went bankrupt, were acquired, or ceased to exist in the following 15 years.” 

Why? “The reasons why complacency sets in can be more emotional than intellectual. In the middle years of your CEO journey, you’re the author of the organization’s status quo. It’s your plan. This makes it far more difficult for you to judge the business dispassionately and to disrupt what’s working well enough. Also, with more success comes increased confidence in your judgment.”

Morgan Stanley’s former CEO James Gorman: “The problem with being a CEO a long time is everybody tells you that you have all the answers. It’s comforting to your ego but very dangerous.”

PepsiCo’s Ramon Laguarta reminds CEOs: “The longer you’re in this role, the greater the risk you think you know everything. You think you’re a hero. You think you know it all. And you think you are the most intelligent person in the room. And you’re not.” (Speaking of heroes and succession, delegate the reading of The Hero’s Farewell to a team member. Read my review.)

No matter what season you’re in—as a CEO or a new leader or manager (or board member)—I guarantee your investment in just the first 112 pages will inspire your leadership and others.
   • Learn why the CEO of a large corporation routinely enjoys coffee and a croissant in the company’s cafeteria every morning at 7:30 a.m.
   • Discover why Intuit’s Brad Smith hosted two meetings per week with eight to 10 people in each group (several levels down) and the three questions he always asked, including: “What’s something you’re afraid no one is telling me that you believe I need to know?”
   • Read how Intel’s Andy Grove and Gordon Moore made a huge decision by walking out of the office—and then back in—with a gutsy new mindset!
   • Learn how Michell Dell of Dell Technologies, 30 years at the helm, found a novel way “to prompt his leadership team to think like outsiders.”

What season are you in? In the “Staying Ahead,” chapter, the authors note that “Between three and five years into their tenure, the best CEOs typically take what they’ve learned and, thinking like an outsider, create the next performance S-curve for their company. (Read more on S-curves in Charles Handy’s book hereRead my review.)

HEART PADDLES! JPMorgan Chase’s Jamie Dimon notes, “Companies are always slowing down, always getting more bureaucratic. Even great people who don’t intend to slow things down tend to do this. You have to constantly fight to improve.” One helpful analogy from another leader: “No one likes change, so you need to create a rhythm of change. Think of it as applying ‘heart paddles’ to the organization.”

OVAL OFFICE NIGHTMARE! I’d buy this book just to soak up the wisdom on CEO succession planning (the fourth season). The authors’ research documents: “A new CEO’s early dismissal is 2.4 times more likely when the outgoing CEO remains the board chair.” Ben Cohen at The Wall Street Journal noted, “Imagine if the former president moved out of the Oval Office but still lived in the White House.”

TO ORDER FROM AMAZON, click on the title for A CEO for All Seasons: Mastering the Cycles of Leadership, by Carolyn Dewar, Scott Keller, Vikram Malhotra, and Kurt Strovink (Senior Partners at McKinsey & Company). Listen on Libro (3 hours, 55 minutes). And thanks to the publisher for sending me a review copy.



BONUS! Three of the four McKinsey co-authors of A CEO for All Seasons also collaborated on the excellent book (no pun intended), CEO Excellence: The Six Mindsets That Distinguish the Best Leaders from the Rest.  Read my review here where I ask the question, "Will you read 1 book or 20 books?"


 

YOUR WEEKLY STAFF MEETING QUESTIONS:
1) Oh, my! The chart on page 24 (one page early for my “Page 25 Rule-of-Thumb”) asks “Do You Really Want to Be a CEO?” The authors deliver 18 options to six questions under three categories:
   • Self-oriented mindset
   • Self-critical mindset
   • Sustainable mindset
See also the chart on page 43: “Are you asking the right questions?” on vision, leadership, team, change, engagement, and measurement. Oh, my! Which question are you asking: “How will I know I’m successful?” or “How will we know if we’re winning?”

2) One CEO shares a brilliant question he asks himself BEFORE he says yes to a future speaking engagement or a meeting (see page 53). “’If this was being asked for today or tomorrow, would I be asking why I’m doing this?’ If that’s true, then we say ‘no’ right now and we just don’t do it.” What’s on your calendar next week? Should you have said "no" two months ago?
 
   
SECOND READS: Fresh Solutions From Classic Books
You have changed—and your problems have changed—since you read this the first time!

Book #28 of 99: The Leader’s Palette

For your team meeting this week, inspire a team member to lead your “10 Minutes for Lifelong Learning” session by featuring Book #28 of 99 in our series, “Second Reads.” The big idea: REREAD TO LEAD! Discover how your favorite books still have more to teach you and the people you’re coaching and mentoring.
The Leader’s Palette: 
Seven Primary Colors

Ralph E. Enlow, Jr. (Feb. 8, 2013)  
 
The warning in the final chapter, “Doxological Leadership,” should be posted on every leader’s morning look-in-the-mirror: “Celebrity will seduce you before you know it. If you have to self-promote in order to get the opportunities you seek, you are selling out. Your capacity to move people toward God will be slowly supplanted by your ambition.”
   • Reviewed in Issue No. 274, April 12, 2013.
   • Order from Amazon.
   • Read John's review on Amazon.
   • Management Bucket #8 of 20: The Culture Bucket

Leverage this book for coaching and mentoring, personal renewal, and staff meeting enrichment. Arresting PowerPoint slides jump off almost every page:
   • “You can’t make up in training what you lack in selection.”
   •  “Leaders ignore culture at their peril.”
 

CLICK HERE FOR BOOKS BY JOHN

    
Read my “Mistake #5: Thinking Leadership Is Learned by Magic,” and how I missed the memo about SMART goals in Mastering Mistake-MakingSee the list of all 25 mistakes here.


Save the Date!
Oct. 30, 2025
Irvine, Calif.


New and Improved! The Barnabas Group/Orange County is hosting a seminar at Concordia University in Irvine, Calif., on Oct. 30, 2025, Thursday 7:30 – 11:30 a.m. Nonprofit CEOs and board members (and pastors) are invited to learn about “The 8 Big Mistakes to Avoid With Your Nonprofit Board: How Leaders Enrich Their Ministry Results Through God-Honoring Governance.” Presented by John Pearson, the 4th edition of the workbook, available at the seminar, will include EIGHT, not just four BIG mistakes!! More info here.


Coming!

Watch for my review of William Vanderbloemen’s new book, Work How You Are Wired: 12 Data-Driven Steps to Finding a Job You Love (Oct. 7, 2025). For background, read my review here of his 2023 book, Be the Unicorn.

No comments:

Post a Comment

A CEO for All Seasons

  Issue No. 658 of  Your Weekly Staff Meeting (Oct. 3, 2025)   features a new book coming Oct. 7—describing the four seasons of a CEO. The “...